To be honest, I was excited to have this opportunity to examine the literature in depth and to create something useful out of it. If I feel there is some good material in the paper but it needs a lot of work, I will write a pretty long and specific review pointing out what the authors need to do.
For example, a strong point may be the introduction of new information, and a drawback may be the lack of accuracy in representing the existing knowledge on the topic.
An example by Gordon Korman book review by Mr. I want to give them honest feedback of the same type that I hope to receive when I submit a how to start writing a review paper. The soundness of the entire peer-review process depends on the quality of the reviews that we write.
After all, even though you were selected as an expert, for each review the editor has to decide how much they believe in your assessment. Afternoons I often spent writing at my apartment or at the library on campus. Just as it seems that the boys are going to finally solve their problems and have a great summer, another problem arises that they have to solve, or else they will have to go back home to Owen Sound as the total failures that their parents expect: I am more willing to review for journals that I read or publish in.
I always read the paper sequentially, from start to finish, making comments on the PDF as I go along. If the paper has horrendous difficulties or a confused concept, I will specify that but will not do a lot of work to try to suggest fixes for every flaw. The article review outline usually goes like this: Would there have been a better way to test these hypotheses or to analyze these results?
I should also have a good idea of the hypothesis and context within the first few pages, and it matters whether the hypothesis makes sense or is interesting. I make a decision after drafting my review.
Getting started Our topic was caspase substrates, a diverse group of proteins essential for programmed cell death and thus important to our understanding of how to kill cancer cells. I look forward to doing it again someday, perhaps in a somewhat more efficient manner.
Third, I consider whether the results or the proposed methodology have some potential broader applicability or relevance, because in my opinion this is important. I even selectively check individual numbers to see whether they are statistically plausible.
I see it as a tit-for-tat duty: If there are things I struggle with, I will suggest that the authors revise parts of their paper to make it more solid or broadly accessible. For me, the first question is this: Demonstrate how the evidence supports the argument in the article.
There are a few aspects that I make sure to address, though I cover a lot more ground as well. At the same time, he becomes a genius in the kitchen, which helps him later on in the story.
Does the author convey his or her thoughts clearly? Most of the time is spent closely reading the paper and taking notes. Supplement what you read with what you already know about the subject-matter.
I never use value judgments or value-laden adjectives. Then I read the Methods section very carefully. How is it structured?What this handout is about This handout will help you write a book review, a report or essay that offers a critical perspective on a text.
It offers a process and suggests some strategies for writing book reviews.
What is Continued. Aug 25, · How to Write a Review. To write a review, start by taking detailed notes while you try out the product or service so you will have specific things to comment on.
Start writing your review by briefly describing or summarizing your experience. Then, use complete sentences to add in details and don't be afraid to use descriptive 76%(61).
Dec 08, · How to Write an Article Review. An article review is both a summary and an evaluation of another writer's article. Start your review by referring to the title and author of the article, the title of the journal, and the year of publication in the first paragraph. "Yes, it helped.
I am writing a paper for class and was unsure 90%(). Writing a Review Paper Most graduate students will need and benefit by writing a review paper on their subject matter central to their thesis topic. How to Write an Article Review.
Sep 07, Types of Academic Writing. An article review is a type of professional paper writing. It demands a high level of in-depth analysis and a well-structured presentation of arguments. When you know the answers to these questions, you may start writing your literature review.
Below are examples.
How to review a paper. I use annotations that I made in the PDF to start writing my review; that way I never forget to mention something that occurred to me while reading the paper.